Monthly Archives: October 2017

Dominion: My Favorite Game for Repeated Play

I like to play a lot of different styles of board games, and I’ve written numerous times on this blog about them. My wife and I own a wide variety of games, but my single favorite game is actually one that you won’t find on that list: Dominion.

Dominion Basics

I first started playing Dominion regularly some time in 2009, a year after it came out. A group of friends in Avery previously got together often to play a variety of games, led by a grad student named Matt Loh who was a big board game aficionado. Pretty quickly, Dominion started being the only game we wanted to play.

As the rulebook introduces the game,

You are a monarch, like your parents before you, a ruler of a small pleasant kingdom of rivers and evergreens. Unlike your parents, however, you have hopes and dreams! You want a bigger and more pleasant kingdom, with more rivers and a wider variety of trees. You want a Dominion! In all directions lie fiefs, freeholds, and feodums. All are small bits of land, controlled by petty lords and verging on anarchy. You will bring civilization to these people, uniting them under your banner.

But wait! It must be something in the air; several other monarchs have had the exact same idea. You must race to get as much of the unclaimed land as possible, fending them off along the way. To do this you will hire minions, construct buildings, spruce up your castle, and fill the coffers of your treasury. Your parents wouldn’t be proud, but your grandparents, on your mother’s side, would be delighted.

The basics of Dominion are pretty simple: You start the game with seven coppers and three estates, meager cards that don’t do much but allow you to buy other cards which then enter your deck and can be played in the future. For instance, you can buy a Silver card for $3 using three Coppers, which you play, but keep in your deck. Then when you play that Silver in a future turn, it will provide you $2 to purchase other cards like Gold, eventually building up to Provinces, which cost $8:

The first conceit of the game is that the Victory cards (Estate, Duchy and Province above) are necessary for winning the game but slow down your deck while you have them. Most strategies, then, build up more and more before eventually “greening,” that is, buying the victory cards that will score the highest points. The first challenge in Dominion is therefore figuring out the best time to start greening.

All six of these cards (along with a seventh I’ll introduce soon) are used in every game; you can always buy them until their pile runs out. Speaking of which, it’s worth mentioning that there are always 8 or 12 cards in each victory pile stack to start — 8 if you only have two players, and 12 if you have three or four. (The treasure piles are large enough that they only very rarely are exhausted.)

A Different Kingdom Every Time

But this wouldn’t be that interesting if those were the only options! Every game of Dominion also features ten randomly chosen (or thoughtfully selected) Action cards, like these:

By default, you begin every turn with a hand of five cards. You then are allowed to play one Action card, then spend your money and buy a card. So for instance, if you played a Smithy, you would now have 7 cards (five, minus one for the Smith you played, plus three) and could spend whatever money you drew. If you drew another Smithy, though, you wouldn’t be able to play it since you’ve used up your one action for the turn.

The Market illustrates the four basic rewards a card can give you: You draw a card, can play another Action this turn, can buy an additional card this turn, and have $1 more to spend. You can see that having a bunch of Markets in your deck would be a lot better than a bunch of Smithies because you could keep on playing them, getting more and more coins and buys. Hence Market costs more than Smithy, $5 rather than $4.

The second key card is in the Village card, which in addition to replacing itself in your hand increases your number of actions. This would let you play, for instance, a Smithy, and then continue to play action cards like Market thereafter. One Village-Smithy pair increases your hand size by 2, so getting a bunch of these together can build up bigger and bigger turns until you’re drawing your whole deck.

Everything I’ve described so far makes Dominion sound like a solitaire game. Sure, there’s some interaction in when you start buying provinces, but everyone is otherwise just trying to improve their own decks in whatever way possible. But fortunately, that’s not all to the game; there are also attack cards like Militia and Witch. Militia makes everyone else discard their hands for next turn down to three cards; you can see why not every turn begins with a five-card hand. (Technically, you draw your next hand at the end of your previous turn.)

Witch, on the other hand, hands everyone else a Curse, which is the seventh card that’s always in play. You wouldn’t want to buy it, but you’re happy to give it to your opponents. There are always enough Curses in the deck for ten Witches to be played; you obviously want to play more of them than your opponent(s) if you can.

But life isn’t always about attacking each other; there’s also a Council Room, which lets everyone draw a card! Our group in Avery decided that every time someone plays a Council Room, we needed to say “yay” while drawing the card.

The next big conceit of Dominion is in the Chapel card. Of course if you have some Curses, you’d love to get a Chapel to cleanse your deck of them. But perhaps the surprising thing is that Chapel is a very good card without any cursing, since you can trash those starting coppers and estates to build a more concentrated, smaller deck. It’s commonly cited as the best card in Dominion relative to its cost. Finally, Gardens is the other game-warping card in the base set, in the opposite direction of Chapel. With Gardens and the right combination of other cards (typically +Buy cards like Market), you want to get as many cards in your deck as possible, often even buying coppers for free with those extra buys.

Finally, how does the game end? There are two possible ending conditions: All the Provinces are bought, or any three of other the sixteen piles are emptied. (Each Action pile has 10 cards in it, while there are always as many Gardens as Provinces.) Generally speaking, the Provinces are sort of the default game end condition, but if either everyone is so bogged down in Curses that they settle for Duchies or otherwise go for an alternative strategy like Gardens, three piles might empty first.

Nothing really replaces playing the actual game, but I hope that this taste of some of the basic strategy tradeoffs that players face with just the cards in the base set of Dominion to give you an idea of how it all works. One of my favorite parts is that it is inherently rather apolitical; apart from the timing of ending the game, most decisions you make affect everyone equally.

Expansions Upon Expansions

What makes Dominion ultimately special and endlessly replayable, though, is all of the expansions that have come out since 2009. Designer Donald X Vaccarino had been planning on releasing several expansions from the beginning, and he assembled them into expansions that started coming out once or twice a year. The first was Intrigue:

Something’s afoot. The steward smiles at you like he has a secret, or like he thinks you have a secret, or like you think he thinks you have a secret. There are secret plots brewing, you’re sure of it. At the very least, there are yours. A passing servant murmurs, “The eggs are on the plate.” You frantically search your codebook for the translation before realizing he means that breakfast is ready. Excellent. Everything is going according to plan.

Each expansion introduces some new mechanics as well as capturing a new theme or five. The first expansion, Intrigue, introduced more cards with different choices, types, and player interaction, like these:

For instance, here’s Nobles, an Action-Victory card. For its action, moreover, you have a choice: A weak Village (no +1 Card), or a Smithy. You can see how this would pair nicely with such a deck; if you have a smithy, he can be a village, or vice-versa. On top of that, he gives two points to boot, allowing you to green a little bit later.

Masquerade is probably still my all-time favorite card because of its unique interaction. After drawing two cards (not a small feat), you pass a card around the circle, or just back and forth if there are only two of you. Then you have a chance to trash a card, often the one you were just passed. Even though it helps to thin your deck, Masquerade forces you to keep around bad cards to pass to other players. There are a lot of interesting interactions to go with it.

Intrigue also introduced one of the most brutal attacks in Torturer that single-handedly unfortunately ruined Dominion for some of my friends before they could really get into it. The attack is not really that bad alone; it’s the player’s choice whether they want to be Militia’d or Witched. But the problem comes when multiple Torturers are played, either by one player or by everyone. Notice how it doesn’t say “Discard down to three,” but “discard two,” meaning that you keep having to discard until you have no hand. Once the curses run out, the attack means nothing, so this should eventually be the goal. But in our 3- and 4-player games, no one wants to be the person who ends up with all the curses, so everyone would tend to discard, making the attack just as powerful as ever. We started to just veto Torturer whenever it came up randomly.

All you ask is a tall ship and a star to steer her by. And someone who knows how to steer ships using stars. You finally got some of those rivers you’d wanted, and they led to the sea. These are dangerous, pirate-infested waters, and you cautiously send rat-infested ships across them, to establish lucrative trade at far-off merchant-infested ports. First, you will take over some islands, as a foothold. The natives seem friendly enough, crying their peace cries, and giving you spears and poison darts before you are even close enough to accept them properly. When you finally reach those ports you will conquer them, and from there you will look for more rivers. One day, all the rivers will be yours.

Seaside came out around the time I started playing, and I remember it being really popular with our group. I joined a little later than some of the others, but we were all trying to figure out these new cards in Seaside together. There were new card types and even some tokens:

Seaside brought in Duration cards like Wharf that have an effect both the turn you play them and the next turn. To keep track, you need to remember to set the wharf aside after playing; it’s bright orange to tell you this. Seaside also introduced mats and tokens. Island provides a mat on which to store cards you want to keep but not until the end, like Provinces or maybe your starting Estates. Finally, Embargo uses its own specialized tokens to keep track of which cards come with a curse when you buy them. Naturally, these new mechanics provide all sorts of interesting opportunities that we got to discover together, like that Wharf is one of the strongest $5 cards in the game, since drawing two cards at the start of your turn is so powerful.

I could keep going, but I think you get the picture. Each new expansion comes along and introducing some new mechanic and potentially breaking some unwritten rule like there being no $7 or $1 cost cards. It was thrilling to discover these things together as a community.

A Whole Day of Dominion-Based Activities

If you haven’t heard of it before, Caltech has a pretty cool Ditch Day tradition: In groups with their friends, seniors plan puzzles and activities for the underclassmen to enjoy for the entire day. These puzzles are called “stacks” (for historical reasons) and generally include a theme of some kind.

My friend group ended up including several of the regular Dominion-playing crowd, and it became the clear pick for our theme. We decided to make stations based on each of the expansions that had come out to date: Intrigue, Seaside, Alchemy, Prosperity, and Hinterlands. For instance, the puzzle at the Seaside station required them to navigate a RC boat in a pool, except the person holding the controller would be turned away from the pool.

Ditch Day Stack

All of us who were part of the Dominion Stack in 2012, wearing our matching t-shirts. 🙂

My favorite puzzle, Intrigue, was one I shamelessly stole from a stack in another house the year before. We found a house near campus with several different rooms, and escorted each of the team members into four different rooms. In each room was a laptop with limited communication ability. Room A had a microphone that would speak to Room B, which had a one-way text chat that would be seen by Room C, which had a microphone to speak to Room D, which had a one-way text chat that would be seen by Room A. Three of the rooms had a sticky note with a word on it, and the fourth room was supposed to assemble all of those messages to give them a hint about where to look in their room for a secret codeword that would release them.

The best part of it all was that we were also secretly logged into those chat rooms, so we could see at least half of the communication going on. It was very entertaining to read all of their half-baked theories of the communication structure — one even involved me as a part of the loop.

Online Dominion: No more shuffling!

Shortly after learning about the game, I found out that I could play it online at BrettSpielWelt for free. A couple of years later, an unofficial server at Isotropic became quite popular and spread among our community. This led to a bit of a revival of interest in Dominion for the same friend group in Avery, only we were mostly playing each other on our own computers whenever Matt wasn’t around.

Online play also allows players to easily resign without feeling like they need to clean up the whole game. You can play the same number of games in a third of the time or less.

The “Great Hall” of Isotropic, where players could propose matches with each other or request to be automatically matched. Screenshot taken from the Dominion Strategy Wiki.

Isotropic unfortunately eventually met its end in March 2013, as the official license was granted to a series of companies to develop an official version of the game. I played the first new version a little bit but was ultimately disappointed with it and generally stopped playing online Dominion.

Said no more gainin’ actions, we’ll be countin’ cards

Fortunately, though, it helped that I had found a new group to play with: friends from the Graduate Christian Fellowship. In fall 2013, several of us in the group started playing pretty regularly after our large group meetings on Friday nights. Most of them lived in Tang, another high-rise graduate dorm on the other side of campus to where I live now. Eventually I decided my various expansions were better served with them, and after not too much time we’d completely forgotten who originally bought which. (We accidentally duplicated efforts and both bought Hinterlands, so I kept my copy for a while until selling it in Eastgate around a year ago.)

This was all around the time when Counting Stars was playing on the radio all the time, and at one point in February 2014, one of our group Adam Hannon made a cover of the song called Counting Cards:

Lately, I’ve been, I’ve been losin’ sleep
Playin’ Dominion up in 20B
But baby, I’ve been I’ve been playin’ hard
Said no more gainin’ actions
We’ll be countin’ cards


Take that Duchy, end your turn
Sink in the Trash the Curses I’ve earned

We continued to accumulate expansions, playing the new ones when we got them. After Adam graduated and moved away, he left behind the expansions he had contributed as a gift. Fortunately, the rest of us kept playing, albeit more and more occasionally.

When Grace arrived at MIT the next year, I knew she was into board games, so I invited her along to our board game nights (this was even before we were dating). We threw her in the deep end, with all of the expansions we had so far at once, but she caught on quickly. One of her first nights playing, we played four 4-player games and both of us finished first and second in some order in all four games. That’s how I knew she was a keeper. 😉

As this friend group from GCF slowly but surely graduated and moved away, we started playing less and less Dominion together. We still have all of the sets together in one place, but haven’t played together in months.

Online Dominion returns

The previous contract for online Dominion expired at the end of 2016, and it was instead awarded to a new company called Shuffle iT started by a regular Dominion player who goes by Stef online. He created a new client from scratch, and on my first impression, it looked like the best iteration of online Dominion yet. I decided to give it a try.

The new website uses a subscription model, but you can play a surprising amount without paying anything. The base set is free, and there are two subscription levels corresponding to half or all of the heretofore-released expansions. But when two players play, you play with the bigger of the two sets, which means that as long as you’re fine playing other people who have a subscription, you don’t need one yourself.

As you can see, there is an option to be automatically matched with someone close to your ability level, as well as an easy way to find your friends and play with them. You can also play against a bot, although it will only play with whatever expansions you’re subscribed to. And if you’re only familiar with some of the cards, you can mark those and (under advanced options) restrict your games to only having a small number of unfamiliar cards. It’s a great system for both beginners and experienced players.

Without sounding too much like a salesman, the subscriptions are also very flexible: You pick when you want them to expire, and in addition to a small transaction fee, you can pay a pro-rated cost of only a few dollars per month. This can work great, say, if you just want to play some Dominion over Christmas break and then get back to work after that.

Could I win some money?

After having played a lot of Dominion over the summer, I wanted a good way to finish it off. I found out about a tournament that would be taking place in mid-September through mid-November, and signed up for it. The entrance fee was simply to have the full subscription active through the end of the tournament.

By the end, 389 total players signed up, and the tournament was set up as a giant single elimination bracket. We were seeded by rating, and I came in at seed #40, which gave me a bye in the first round. There’s been a round per week so far, and we just finished Round 6.

And I’m somehow still in it, which means I’m in the top 8 and guaranteed a prize of 6 months of the top subscription level. The top four get cash prizes ranging from 50€ to 500€; there’s a bronze medal match to determine 3rd and 4th place. I don’t know yet who my opponent in the next round will be or when I’ll be playing, but you’re welcome to log in and cheer me on. 🙂

A Spooky Expansion

The other exciting news in Dominion world this fall is that a new expansion is coming out next month! Set to release on November 13th, Nocturne is a bit of a Halloween-themed expansion full of werewolves, vampires, ghosts, and zombies. Here’s its flavor text:

NocturneYou’ve always been a night person; lately you’ve even considered becoming a vampire. There are a lot of advantages: you don’t age; you don’t have to see yourself in mirrors anymore; if someone asks you to do something, you can just turn into a bat, and then say, sorry, I’m a bat. There are probably some downsides though. You always think of the statue in the town square, that came to life, and now works as the tavern barmaid. The pedestal came to life too, so she has to hop around. The village blacksmith turns into a wolf whenever there’s a full moon; when there’s a crescent moon, he turns into a chihuahua. That’s how this stuff goes sometimes. Still, when you breathe in the night air, you feel ready for anything.

This week, Donald X. has released a series of five previews, along with five bonus previews (also at the same link), of the new themes and most of the cards in the expansion. And to make it even more enticing, you can actually play with the previewed cards in the online client for free this whole weekend only. Sorry if you had other plans. 😉

It’s been nearly ten years since Dominion first came out, and it’s still as popular as ever. With the release of Nocturne previews, the Dominion Strategy forum had its highest viewership day ever earlier this week.

If you have a group of friends to get together with regularly, Dominion is a great game to dive headlong into. To be completely honest, most of the games that I own get old after you play them too much. That’s simply not the case with Dominion; I have literally played thousands of games and have yet to bore of it. Having introduced the game to a bunch of different sets of friends, I can guarantee you’ll love the diversity of games, the interesting strategy and tactics required, and the speed at which most games finish. As with anything, it helps to have someone experienced to guide you through it, or just to play online ahead of time to get a feel for the game before buying a physical copy. But it’s definitely worth the investment. 🙂

Happy Dominionating!

Where do your review cycles run?

I’m currently taking the second year of the Chinese curriculum here at MIT, and as anyone learning another language knows, there’s a lot to remember. It can be easy to focus on the short term and review just the most recent vocabulary and characters we’ve learned, but the class is cumulative; I am often asked to read or recall anything we’ve learned in the first year as well.

Naturally, this means that I need to regularly review the old material on a semi-regular basis, using Quizlet flashcards created by one of my classmates that match up with the text. But the exact mechanics of how I do so are not as important as the fact that I’m reviewing at all. In fact, after I took one year of Chinese, I decided to try to take a break and gauge whether I’d be able to keep it up long-term. After a year of doing so, I was satisfied with how much I was able to retain that I decided to go for one more year.

Languages like this are rather conspicuous examples; if you don’t use them, you lose them. I’m already (sadly) planning on allowing the German I learned in middle school and high school to fade gracefully, rather than latching onto the few German-speaking peers and starting conversations with them just to keep it up.

But it’s helpful to think in terms of review cycles in many other areas, too, especially those where we need to make intentional effort to do or be something.

Read more of this post

Ten New Games for Long Car Rides

October is the month for retreating in New England. This week I’m in between two retreats to New Hampshire, my 11th and 12th fall retreats there in my six years of grad school — I’ve gone to all six math department retreats, four with my church, and two with the Graduate Christian Fellowship.

Retreats in grad school have provided what frisbee tournaments in college and sightseeing across the Western US in my childhood did: Long car or bus rides. When I’m not sleeping, getting to know or catching up with people, or just pontificating on society in general together, it’s often the right context to play some kind of game with the other passengers.

But given the moving environment and constrained seating positions, such rides don’t easily lend themselves to nearly any of the board games in our collection. Card games like Hanabi or A Game for Good Christians probably come closest but often those need some kind of surface to play onto. Growing up, my siblings and I would keep a wooden tray under one of the seats in our mini-van, which we would then place on the armrests of the two captain’s chairs for such a surface on which to play card games, but that was always a bit imperfect as cards would slide around whenever we went around a windy mountain road.

In this post, though, I want to focus on games that don’t require any advance preparation or equipment. Many of these games typically spread by word-of-mouth, but I’m hoping that by articulating them in a blog post, we can speed up that process. They aren’t all “new” per se, but unless you spend a lot of time around me, I can almost guarantee you haven’t heard of half of these. Without further ado, here are the categories:

Read more of this post

Turning Off the Noise

One of my favorite albums of all time is Switchfoot’s The Beautiful Letdown (2003). In addition to the radio smash hits Dare You to MoveThis is Your Life, and Gone, the album also featured a song that I initially found a little strange. Here’s the chorus:

If we’re adding to the noise
turn off this song
If we’re adding to the noise
turn off your stereo, radio, video

Why would the band be telling you to turn off their music? Is this some weird reverse psychological tactic?

Read more of this post